Meet Your Seller

Sherri Coultrup

@fayettevillepiccadillycircus

We're a small, woman owned business in Fayetteville, NC. We carry vintage and antiques as well as an array of unique treasures. Our idea of a good time is going on treasure hunts for the oddest or weirdest things we can find.

NNiknax seller since Feb 21, 2024
746 Listings
345th on Seller Leaderboard
10 Sales
2 days avg. time to ship

Vintage Winston Give a Penny Take a Penny

This authentic Winston penny tray embodies mid-century American retail culture with its enduring "Give a Penny Take a Penny" motif. A genuine artifact of vintage advertising, it showcases the communal spirit that once defined neighborhood commerce. Ideal for serious collectors of period memorabilia or vintage enthusiasts seeking a conversation-starting accent piece with documented historical provenance. Note: features a visible crack consistent with its age and use.

5 views
Listed Jan 9, 2026

$26.00 + shipping

From the SellerA right-pointing triangle. Rotate or flip with Tailwind classes to change direction.

NiknaxA right-pointing triangle. Rotate or flip with Tailwind classes to change direction.

Primitive Antique Fancy Adjustable Betty- Grease-Whale Oil/ Candle Lamp

Tiffany & Co. Ring Vintage Classic 1837 Concave Medium Band Sterling Silver 5.75

Vintage Goofy Phone

Sterling Silver Opal Ring Sz 9.25

Judith Ripka Sterling Silver 925 Citrine & CZ Circle Link Chain Toggle Bracelet 7.5”

Sterling Silver John Hardy Pendant

Judith Ripka Sterling Silver Stackable Turquoise Bangle Bracelet Signed

Vintage Tiffany & Co 925 Sterling Silver Marked Peretti Spain Chain With Murano Glass Bead 925 Sterling Silver Tea Pot Charm

Sterling Silver Gemstone Cluster Ring Size 5.75

Vintage & Rare Sterling Silver Tiffany & Co Charm Bracelet 7.5”

Mid Century Studio Laurana Italy Copper Enameled Oblong Dish 13.75”

Rare Antique Consolidated Glass Company Poppies Satin Vaseline Glass 2 Piece Fairy Lamp 7”

Tiffany & Co T Cuff Bracelet Sterling Silver

Michael Dawkins Sterling Silver Bangle Coated Topaz & MOP

Vintage 10K Gold Filled Chyrsoprase Ring Size 6

INSPIRADO BREAD BOX, Stonelite Ceramic Lemon design w/ Blue - Covered

Vintage Iridescent Costume Ring Size 8

RARE Limited Edition Fenton Lotus Mist Burmese Glass 3 Piece Fairy Light 7 1/2” Excellent Condition Includes All Paperwork #380 Out Of 1,950

#01 Silpada B1936 Sterling Silver Hematite Hailstone 5-Strand Necklace

Vintage Native American Sterling Silver Green Stone Ring Size 9.5

Product Gallery

Vintage Winston Give a Penny Take a Penny

Sherri CoultrupA right-pointing triangle. Rotate or flip with Tailwind classes to change direction.

Vintage Fenton Northern star marigold glass tray

Emerald green crackle glass pitcher

Bohemian Cranberry Red cut to clear crystal rose bowl

Vintage Fenton hobnail blue glass salt cellar

Vintage pink trimmed 4 leaf clover trinket dish

Yellow Hull art pottery Serenade pitcher

Smoking Joes Racing Tin

Vintage Ceramic ashtray featuring Village of Tobbaccoville

Vintage Camel Special lights cigarette tin

Vintage Bartlett Collings bud vase with red base gold stripes

Imperial glass marigold "Beaded bullseye swung vase

Jeweled faberge style decorative eggs with floral design

Yellow Hull art pottery vase

Contemporary pottery "Wild Boy"

Fenton Rosalene pink rabbit

Fenton Rosalene pink pedestal compote candy dish

Fenton Rosaline Pink footed Rose bowl

Cobalt blue ashtray

Winston lights branded plastic tumbler with lid